Fall 2018 – Week 3

Bllom into You - Yuu accepts Touku

Bloom into You was… just wow this week, the strongest episode this week and arguably of the season so far.  Tsurune finally premiers, and doesn’t wow me at all.  All this and more after the jump!


The shows that I am watching are in bold, shows my wife and I are watching together are in bold italics, and strikethrough marks dropped shows.

A Certain Magical Index III Eps 1-3

Index is back, along with all it’s pseudo-religious pseudo-magical gobbledygook and massively overpowered MC.  I mean seriously, people complain about Kirito but not about a guy who can stop any attack (magical or technological) simply by using his right hand?  WTF is up with that?

That being said, yah, I’m glad it’s back and I’m enjoying it in all it’s utterly ridiculous over-the-top glory.

The most interesting development so far is in Ep 3…  Touma’s memory loss has been a Chekov’s gun on the mantelpiece since the middle of the 1st season, and they finally pulled the trigger.  Now it’s out in the open…  and Misaka (Railgun) is pissed.  To be honest though, I don’t remember enough of the story to tell/know whether she’s pissed at him or for him.

Anima Yell! Ep 3

Basically your bog standard “now that we’re a club, what do we do” episode..  Except, they’re not a club (yet) so they don’t really get any support from the school other than an assigned practice space.  Also standard, a member (Kohane) studying hard with the help of her clubmates to improve the club’s chances.  Yeah, though standard it does show how determined she is when it comes to cheer.

The latter part of the episode was interesting.  Asked to cheer for someone in a situation where cheering isn’t really applicable, they still sit and hear her out and offer advice and support.

Anima Yell! - Kohane.png
Also, HUGE shout outs and props for taking the situation seriously and not laughing, jeering, or shaming.

Bloom Into You / Yagate Kimi ni Naru Ep 3


Bloom into You - Touko leans on Yuu
Bllom into You - Yuu accepts Touku
That was…  one h_ll of an episode.

Touku continues to court Yuu, but she’s not being a stalker or being creepy or forceful.  She’s just being her.  She’s simply there as a friend without forcing her attentions.  On her part, Yuu still doesn’t ‘get’ this love stuff..  But without even realizing it herself, she’s starting to accept Touku, as a close friend if nothing else.

And that all culminates in the scene above.  I’ve seen kissing scenes aplenty, and more than a few (implied if nothing else) sex scenes, and every variant you can imagine…  But I don’t think I’ve ever seen a scene as poignantly, beautifully,  intimate as the ones in the screenie…  Tooku takes the ultimate, irrevocable, step of opening her true self to Yuu and she accepts it unconditionally.

Bunny Girl Senpai Ep 4
Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai / Seishun Buta Yarou wa Bunny Girl-senpai no Yume wo Minai

Sakata gets some great lines, doesn’t he?

It seems the anime is going to follow the structure of the light novels, one volume on one girl and then move onto the next.  Not a bad structure overall, and I’m glad it takes the form of a continuing story rather than resetting reality each volume.  Though resetting reality could make for an interesting meta-tale given the stories already revolve around resetting reality.  One interesting consequence of this is now that Sakata is involved in solving Tomoe’s problem, he’s also faced with working things out with Mai.  She’s a strong willed cuss and unlikely to make that an easy task.

Iroduku Sekai no Ashita kara / IRODUKU : The World in Colors Ep 3

There was a lot of comment this week about Hitomi using a Pocky (sorry, “Popocky”) while she was trying to get the coffee cup to levitate.  I think some of that is because we’re used to Harry Potter and various kinds of RPG’s, where a wand is intrinsically magical.  Here it seems to be used more as an aid to concentration, which makes sense to me as her Great-Grandmother emphasized focusing.  That also seems to be consistent with the water walking scene…  As long as she believed she could do it, everything was fine.  But when she was distracted… splash!

Iroduku - Hitomi walks on water.
There was also some commentary about the Photography Club’s competence and approach to recruiting members….  All I’ll say at the moment is that looking at it as a photographer and someone who sometimes teaches photography it’s not as simple an issue as it appears.  There’s more than meets the untrained eye and I’m still ruminating on how to express that.

Release the Spyce Ep 3

The first part, Momo’s confidence and skill issues, went past pretty fast…  we’ve all seen that before.  The second part, where we finally get a good look at the villain group was much better…  Interesting that they hire/rely on mercenaries rather than having their own troops.  I don’t think I’ve ever seen that before.  Loved the action scene with Momo and Fu battling Byakoo…  Classic!

The mystery here, who is the traitor?  For some reason I can’t see any of the senpais being a traitor…  So it’s either one of the other apprentices or (my pick) the curry shop girl.

Run with the Wind / Kaze ga Tsuyoku Fuiteiru Ep 4

Run with the Wind - Kakeru's decision..png
So Kakeru hates his past self…  Not just the events with the running club, but gambling and the consequences of that too.  And it wasn’t just one instance either, he was sleeping rough even before he no longer had money for food – and chose gambling over food.

That being said, it’s still not entirely clear to me exactly what his past trauma was or what role the former friend will play.

I laughed my _ss off at The Prince’s monologue and it’s untimely ending.  :)  We still don’t know what Haiji sees in him, but his character is finally emerging.

Sword Art Online: Alicization Ep 3

Basically, the third ep was a recap of the first two eps…  Which is annoying because the second ep was largely a recap of the first.  Dammit SAO, even though I’m a confirmed fanboy, even my patience is wearing thin.

Fortunately, the final moments of the ep promise that we’ll see some action soon.  On the flip side, it’s a depressingly familiar SAO scenario – there’s a damsel in distress and Kirito has to come to her rescue.   Want to know the reasons Asuna is Best Girl?  She’s never been a cardboard cutout in need of rescue.  She couldn’t escape Sugou’s trap on her own – but she damn well tried.  She faced down the monster lungfish thing.  Kirito and her mother have both tried to steer her onto a path, and she’s told ’em both to go pound sand.  And when Kirito was dying because of Kuradeel’s treachery, she took it on herself to be the one doing the rescuing.

Ahem, ok, enough of that.

Though SAO is not a harem anime (no matter what the clueless critics say), this habit is why the charge of being one is so often leveled against it.

The Girl in Twilight / Akanesasu Shoujo Ep 4

A western themed world?  Now they’re just being silly.  And how long will it take them to figure out that things aren’t happening by chance?

I think I can predict how the rest of the show will go…  Each girl in turn will have her personal issues worked out and gain the ability to become an Equalizer.  In the final ep, they’ll confront the Big Bad.  It’s all been done before.  Trying to find how many eps Twilight is supposed to have I came across something I’d forgotten – the anime is a promo for a mobile game.  Yeah, that just increases the feeling that they aren’t going to color outside the lines and explains a lot about the show so far.

Kudos though for not making the game play elements too obvious, that’s actually pretty rare.

That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime / Tensei Shitara Slime Datta Ken

Reincarnated as a Slime - EILF.png
I don’t have anything useful to say about Slime this week…  But I couldn’t help but admire this joke.

Tsurune / Tsurune: Kazemai Koukou Kyuudou-bu Ep 1

So far, pretty much a standard setup for a sports/club anime.  Of course, being Kyoani, it’s a lushly produced and well-directed standard sports anime!

But being Kyoani can’t save it from being compared to Run with the Wind and Tsurune comes off the field in a losing position.  They threw a ton of characters at us, and none really have any distinguishing characteristics or personalities…  They’re pretty much all archetypes.  I have to work at it to remember them as distinct individuals.  The MC is one we’ve all seen a million times before.  At the end of the episode, I didn’t really feel any tension because of the sense of “BTDT, I have a feeling I know what happens next”.

Tsurune is really going to have to up it’s game in the next couple of episodes to break out of the pack, and I don’t get a feeling it’s going to even try.  It might have rated better in a slower season (such as Spring or Summer of this year) or a season where it wasn’t going head to head with a closely related but better executed show.

=========

I think part of what’s making it easier to write of late isn’t just the shorter form…  As I was working on this week’s entry, I realized I was simply assuming the reader had watched the episode.  Not having to describe what happened unless it’s really relevant and needed saves an awful lot of energy.  Since I think of what I do as more commentary than review, yeah, I’m gonna just roll with that.

Too bad Karandi has already trademarked the concept of the “100 word review”….  (I kid, I kid…)

So how did your week go?  What do think about my thoughts?  Drop a comment and let’s chat!

11 thoughts on “Fall 2018 – Week 3”

  1. I would not be too surprised if Anima Yell! had the Cheerleading club become a “club that helps people” on the side. As for The World in Colours, it is still the series that has my undivided attention: the magic is more tangible than Tolkein’s, but more abstract than Rowling’s; while quite visible, I think that it’s the journey Hitomi goes on that will be the most exciting for me, as opposed to specifics behind how the magic works (for one, I doubt that Gamp’s Law of Elemental Transfiguration applies here!). I’m also watching Alicization at my own pace right now.

    With only three shows on my plate, I’m wondering: are there any series of this season you’d recommend?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That would be an interesting turn for Anima Yell!… I think I’d enjoy that.

      If you’re watching Iroduku, you’re already watching one of my two top picks this season… :) The other is Bloom into You, which is getting very good. Run with the Wind is also well above average.

      Like

  2. @Slime: After everyone praised the joke I finally had to look up the abbreviation. I’d never heard it before. (It’s not easy to translate to e-ru-fu –> ero – fu…) [I sort of blink at that aspect of the show: are all elves female and all dwarves male? So far…]

    @Anima Yell: The coming-out scene was excellent! They got the timing right, and made no big deal out of it. The highlight of a rather standard episode.

    @Bloom into You: Awesome episode! I agree. Both the set-up and the pay-off worked really well.

    @Iroduku: I hope you figure out how to express your thoughts on the recruitment scene. That would make for an interesting post (or an interesting part of a post, depending).

    @Run With the Wind: I’m starting to entertain the possibility that winning isn’t the main point of the exercise. I wonder what kind of relationship Haiji has with the old guy who runs the dorm.

    @Tsurune: I’m not feeling the archery scenes. Too much visual and soundtrack distraction. It’s not bad, but my track-record with in-house KyoAni franchises is… not good.

    @Bunny Girl Senpai: This just doesn’t draw me in. Is there anything special about Sakuta’s syndrome? Why does he get drawn in with all the girls? Protagonist syndrome? Will they be going meta on us? If this were a weekend show, I’d probably drop it. But I’m not watching that much this season, and it’s competing with Beelzebub (which turned out to be surprisingly charming once I warmed up to it, but also isn’t sure-fire keeper), and Space Fish (which I’d rather not pick back up).

    So far, I’m liking this season better than last season. I’m quite happy with what we’re getting.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. re:Anima Yell! I agree, 95% of it is bog standard… But they keep sneaking in that 5%. I don’t think it’s destined for greatness, but it is looking to be better than most of the genre.

      re:Iroduku It’s turning into more of a rant at the moment… But that’s probably because ATM I’m juggling too many balls WRT to the Lounge and the topic is a bit of a hot button in the photography community.

      re:Tsurune We know Kyoani can do subtle… So why is this show being handled with ham fists? That’s what’s bugging me.

      And I agree, this season is definitely looking up. Especially (for me) with Bloom and Iroduku we’re finally getting out from under Winter 2018’s long shadow.

      Like

  3. “Basically, the third ep was a recap of the first two eps… Which is annoying because the second ep was largely a recap of the first.”

    Nailed it in regards to SAO so far. I like the show but man, pick up the pace a bit? I get that Kirito technically doesn’t know all this stuff but the audience does. I enjoy that they are taking a realistic approach and trying to show how Kirito advances but at the same time I think at nearly 2 hours in, we could make some actual progress. That seems reserved for episode 4 however so here’s hoping.

    I thought that joke in Slime was pretty good too XD

    Liked by 1 person

    1. From what I’ve picked up here and there, the adaptation pace isn’t far off the LN’s pace. So, they’re not “doing it wrong” per se… But it is a bit annoying, esp knowing how many episodes (a years worth!) lies ahead of us. If this pace holds, it’s going to be hard to keep people’s attention.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. I agree with you when it comes to Run With the Wind. We don’t know exactly what Kakeru’s past trauma was. Hopefully more of it will be released as the show develops. From the looks of it, he is starting to mesh with his team much quicker than I expected. The lit major just makes me laugh! It makes my day lol.
    Regarding SAO, this season sure is slow paced. I kind of liked seeing Kirito mull over the events and try and make sense of things. It did feel repetitive but it adds to the confusion he’s faced and presents him working through stuff. Though, I do agree with you when it comes to saving damsels. That happens way too often in this show.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. No doubt his trauma is going to form a huge part of the storyline… I mean he is the deuteragonist if not a co-protagonist. I just wish it wasn’t so dragged out. Two shows (Wind and SAO) with a glacial pace in one season is a bit much.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s