Winter 2018 – Week 6 & Midseason thoughts.

Screenshot (392).png

Here we are for another week!  Some really good eps this week, and some that are just average.  Also, my mid-season thoughts on each show.  Hit the jump and let’s get started!


The shows that I am watching are in bold, shows my wife and I are watching together are in bold italics.  Question marks denote shows not watched yet (during the premiere weeks), and strike through marks dropped shows.

A place further than the Universe / Uchuu yorimo Toui Basho – Ep 7

Screenshot (388).png

I’m… not sure how I feel about this episode.  We’re finally on the boat, but something feels like it’s missing.  Seeing the girls finally having to directly confront the same reality as the adults, a very good thing.  Getting to see the resolution of the adult members in the face of those difficulties, also a very good thing.  Finally getting a glimpse of Takako?  Practically the best part of the episode.

But why was there no reaction to Shirase introducing herself?  Surely the majority of the crew knows of her relationship.  Everyone we’ve met so far knows.  Why did I get a creepy cult vibe during Kanae’s speech?   There’s some mysteries here, and they leave me feeling unsettled.  It’s almost like the first episode of a brand new show.

Midseason thoughts: Things have gotten a bit rocky in the last two episodes, but at its rockiest Yorimo is still a damn fine show.  It refuses to settle into a groove, or let the viewer get too comfortable – without relying on cheap plot zigs.

Ancient Magus Bride – Ep 18

Chise finds a friend in Stella, and Elias is…  less than pleased.  OK, he’s jealous as hell that Chise is showing affection to someone other than him.  Unable to handle the flood of emotions he turns bestial and flees the house.  Chise pursues him, but after he metaphorically smothers her, she has to threaten to self-harm to get him to turn her loose.

That’s basically the first half of the episode…  And it was wonderful.  It really showcased how Chise is becoming her own independent person.  This was nicely balanced by Elias having difficulty with handling his own emotions, as he has practically zero experience in even having emotions.

The second half…  Beyond bringing out Chise’s devotion to Elias I have no idea what was going on there.

Midseason thoughts: I’m enjoying Magus Bride, but I’m also getting a bit numb from getting poked in the same spot by the same themes.

citrus – Ep 6

Screenshot (390).png

Wait, what…  Did someone at Crunchyroll stick the wrong disk into the machine or something?  citrus was actually halfway decent this episode.  Mei’s realization of the wrong path she’d been on, Yuzu’s support of Mei and active interventions – solid character moments all.  Might have been a bit better if Daddy hadn’t been such a cardboard cutout stock character…  But other than that, decent melodrama.  (So long as you don’t think too hard about the shaky foundations.)

Midseason thoughts:  The recent half-decent melodrama aside, citrus remains trashy and exploitive at its core.  The next episode preview foretells a plot zig.

How to Keep a Mummy / Miira no Kaikata (ANN) – Ep 5

Well, once again they spent most of the ep with Mii-kun offscreen… and the show suffered heavily because of it.  Asa and Isao just weren’t enough carry the episode.  The constant hints of something dramatic in Tazuki’s background are more annoying than anything else.  Get on with it or drop it.

Midseason thoughts: Mummy started out a decent sitcom, but now it can’t quite decide what it wants to be…  and lacks the foundation to be anything other than a sitcom.

Katana Maidens / Toji No Miko – Ep 6

This episode is best described as “running in place”.  We only learned one new thing, the Elite Guard are using Noro injections to summon the power of the Aradama.  Other than that, a great deal of ado and rushing about over nothing.

Midseason thoughts: Honestly, this show will be the death of me yet.  Its pendulum keeps swinging between “lets stretch this stuff out” and “strap in, we have a lot to cram in this week”.  All the parts are there for a fair-to-middlin’ tale…  It just can’t seem to mesh the parts together smoothly.

March comes in like a Lion

~On Hiatus~

Midseason thoughts:  We’re caught between two arcs, but March has been it’s usual stunning self so far – so I see that continuing.

Märchen Mädchen – Ep 5

As predicted last week…  they certainly were setting up for “the last-minute return of the Heroine”.  Though Hazuki’s newfound support from her modern-world family came kind of out of left field, overall they carried it off much better than I would have expected.  And I’m more convinced than ever that her biological mother was a Mädchen.  I also suspect that her step-mother knows something.

Screenshot (389).png

I can’t help but wonder, what’s the Headmistress’ angle?  She’s putting her thumbs on the scale, why?

Midseason thoughts:  On it’s best days Mädchen has been pretty much generic (strongly influenced by Harry Potter) “magical girls at Battle High School”.  I don’t expect too much, but after the uptick in quality in ep 5 I’m curious to see how things go from here.  Ep 6 could be a make-or-break point.

Ms. Koizumi Loves Ramen Noodles / Ramen Daisuki Koizumi-san – Ep 6

Though Koizumi’s fluency in German did come as a bit of a surprise…  Otherwise, mostly standard hijinks.  I should have expected she’d make her way to the Shin-Yokohama Raumen Museum at some point.

Midseason thoughts:  Koizumi-san is, at best, mostly harmless mind candy.  I’m not learning much new about ramen, but that’s just me as I’ve studied it somewhat.

Slow Start – Ep 6

Screenshot (386).png

This week’s (mostly) Tama-centric episode was much better than last week’s creep-and-stalker fest.  A study session and a sleepover are genre staples for CGDCT, and both were handled… decently.

Midseason thoughts: After a strong start, Slow Start seems determined to settle into a rut of comfortable mediocrity.  In some ways, that’s not actually bad.  CGDCT is generally a comforting genre without much in the way of drama or surprises.  However here it’s being accompanied by the gradual loss of the above average character acting that marked the first few eps.  Multiple one-note characters can create a wonderful harmony, but flat characters are nothing but flat.

Yuru Camp / Laid-Back Camp – Ep 6

Screenshot (387).png

Possibly the slowest episode of a series noted for its slow pace.  But wonderful nonetheless.  Watching Rin and Nadeshiko bond over gadgetry and food was delightful.  I think my only complaint was the rather abrupt stopping point.

Midseason thoughts: Honestly, I’m loving the hell out of it.  Great characters, great acting, wonderful writing and story, wonderful animation…  Really, it’s the whole package.

=========

So, what did you think this week?  What are your thoughts on the season so far?  Drop a line in the comments and let me know.

4 thoughts on “Winter 2018 – Week 6 & Midseason thoughts.”

  1. Miira no Kaikata is near perfect for me – I like all the characters and have no problem whatsoever with the narrative.

    Other than that I might be slightly more positive on Universe and Toji no Miko, but the difference seems negligible. Little to add.

    I think my list might look like this:

    Hakumei to Mikochi (undisputed favourite)
    3-gatsu no Lion 2 (excellent anime)
    Mitsuboshi Colors (bratty children are fun; switches with Yuru Camp every other weak)
    Yuru Camp (very relaxing, best when it narrowly focusses on Rin/Nadeshiko)
    Sora Yori Mo Tooi Basho (energetic and fun)
    Miira no Kaikata (likable and cute)
    Karakai Jouzu no Takagi San (one-trick pony gag show underpinned by a surprisingly subtle romance)
    Koi wa Ameagari no You ni (one of the best direction and writing this season, but at times creepy overtones in the meta game)
    Gakuen Baby Sitters (cute and delicate, if only it didn’t think pedo-jokes were funny – rarely, but still…)
    Mahoutsukai no Yome (the repetitive is both comfortable and a little stale; but the highpoints are really, really high)
    Pop Team Epic (How do you even rank… this?)
    Card Captor Sakura Clear Card Hen (Diminishing returns)
    Kokkoku (Surprisingly gripping; the sort of show that usually fails for me, but I’m hooked)
    Dame X Prince Anime Caravan (Early episodes were a hoot, settled down a bit, but still fun)
    Sanrio Danshi (once again, the early episodes are the best; very character dependent – some are more engaging than others)
    Classicaloid 2 (not quite as good as season 1, as the highpoints are comedy gold)
    Killing Bites (awful trash; but I love the geeky narrator who explains animal trivia)
    Darling in the FranXX (Still not sure about this show)
    Toji no Miko (comfortable middling show)
    Dagashi Kashi 2 (10 minutes is the perfect run-time for this)
    Mitchiri Neko (my sort of humour)
    Ramen Daisuki Koizumi San (it’s amazing how much this show is getting out of its very limited premise)
    Märchen Mädchen (Cute, and in rare moments very good – mostly straightforward fighting show, though)
    Violet Evergarden (melodramatic and full of visual clichés; occasionally good)
    Basilisk 2 (Very uneven; some episodes are actually good, but some are so bad they’re unintentionally funny)
    Osomatsu san 2 (season 2 focusses mostly on gross-out humour which I don’t like, but the rare moment when they actually coat a pretty serious story in their silly brand of humour are so worth wading through the rest)
    Ryuou no Oshigoto (A very good portrayal of master-student relationships and professional shogi relations balanced against an equally awful layer lolicon tripe – the biggest waste of the season; there’s actually a great story here, but it’s damn hard to get to it)
    Beatless (Good SF concept, dull show)
    Overlord 2 (occasionally interesting, occasionally annyoing, mostly just there)
    Gankrest Senki (Unfocused, wastes time with unnecessary stuff and then hurries through the stuff you’d actually need to see developed; a mess of a show – better potential than execution)
    Death March (I should trop this; it’s garbage. Maybe I will)

    I’m still not quite sure whether to watch Citrus or not. Also Nanatsu no Taizai 2. I’m not in a hurry for either show, though. I’m pretty sure I dropped Slow Start for good (it’s better than some stuff on my list – and I might come back to it if I’m ever very, very bored and not in the mood for something more demanding).

    Finally, I’m surprised to find I broke the 30-show barrier… Anything below Osomatsu san 2 can fall to the chopping block, if it goes one step too far (or in the case of Beatless and Gancrest, if I run out of patience). Osomatsu san and above should be safe.

    Like

  2. Regarding A Place Further than the Universe, I attribute the “creepy” vibe of the speech more to the group’s shared experience from the first expedition and the loss of Shirase’s mother. Their vow to return is finally being realized, and I imagine that realization is incredibly moving for each one of them. I also wondered at the response to Shirase’s introduction, since they all know who she is and likely why she’s there. Maybe they have the tact to not make a point about it? I’m not sure if that’s it, but I know were I in their shoes, I probably would want to avoid focusing on her loss unless she brings it up herself.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That’s a good point on the creep factor – she’s speaking to the in-group, not to the audience (us). It’s pretty easy for things to directed at an in-group to sound “off” to those outside the circle.

      I can see not making a fuss over Shirase, that’s going to bring back some bad memories and make things awkward for everyone. But I’d still think there would be more reaction than blank faces. That’s kinda what I was getting at, they didn’t downplay it… they simply didn’t react at all.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s